Fruit & Nut Pies    |    Cream Pies    |    Seasonal & Specialty    |    6" Pies   | Pie Cookies

Regular Menu Pies

Made with only the highest quality fruits and nuts. Each is handcrafted from scratch in our kitchen.

NOT ALL PIES ARE AVAILABLE AT ALL TIMES;  PLEASE CALL FOR AVAILABILITY.

To ensure your favorite is available it is recommended that you pre-order whole pies 48 hours in advance.

All double crust fruit pies are Vegan.

Apple

Hand-peeled and hand-sliced crisp apples mixed with cinnamon, nutmeg, and sugar, then placed between two layers of our handmade flaky crust for apple pie perfection.

Caramel Apple Crunch

Hand-peeled and hand-sliced apples combined with pecans, caramel sauce, sugar, cinnamon, and nutmeg in a flaky single crust. Crumb topping adds a crunchy texture with more pecans, caramel topping, flour, sugar, and butter.

 

Apple Crisp

Hand-peeled and hand-sliced apples soaked in rum before being mixed with cinnamon, nutmeg, and sugar in a flaky single crust. The crumb topping combines oatmeal, flour, brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and butter resulting in the wonderful flavor of an apple crisp made even better with the golden pie crust.

 

Berry Cherry

Combines the tartness of raspberries with the tartness of cherries with just the right amount of sugar for a burst of flavor in a double crust pie.

 

Blackberry Apple

Hand-peeled and hand-sliced apples combined with blackberries and a touch of cardamom (a spice) topped with our oatmeal streusel topping and another touch of cardamom.

Blueberry

A traditional pie packed with the mouth watering goodness of just blueberries in a flaky double crust.

BumbleBerry

A combination of strawberries, raspberries, blueberries, and blackberries with just the right sweet/tart blend in a flaky double crust.

Blueberry Peach

A delightful combination of flavors and textures in a double crust pie.  A customer favorite!

Peaches & Cream

Rich peachy heaven with a smooth creamy base topped with a delectable crumble top.

Cherry Berry

Perfect blend of tart cherries and sweet berries.

Peach

Classic double crust peach pie. Southern goodness up here in the North.

Blackberry Raspberry

A delicious combination of luscious berries. Sweet/tart enveloped in our famous double crust.

Strawberry Raspberry

The sweetness of strawberries combined with the tartness of raspberries in a flaky double crust.

Cherry

The old-fashioned flavor of a traditional cherry pie made with tart cherries in a flaky double crust.

 

Double Lemon

An explosion of lemon taste with the perfect combination of sweetness and tartness in a lemon chess pie (similar to a lemon custard) topped with homemade lemon curd and lemon zest.

Lingonberry Lemon

A delectable combination of tastes with the sweet/tart blending of our lemon chess pie and traditional Swedish Lingonberries.

Pecan

Lightly toasted pecans in a buttery sauce flavored with kahlua and baked in a single flaky crust.

Triple Chocolate Pecan

Chocolate perfection with semi-sweet milk chocolate and white chocolate, coconut, lightly toasted pecans, and sliced almonds layered in a single crust, covered with its own special buttery sauce.

Peanut Butter Fudge

A soft, dark chocolate brownie layer in a single crust topped with a creamy blend of peanut butter, cream cheese, whipped cream, and peanuts. Chocolate drizzled on top completes the perfect blend of chocolate and peanut.

Chocolate Silk

Intensely rich dark chocolate silk in our world famous flaky crust topped with secret recipe homemade whipped cream and dark chocolate shavings. Seasonal, 48 hour notice for special orders.

Ooey Gooey Turtle 

Rich, fudgy chocolate chess pie with a layer of Ghirardelli caramel, toasted pecans, whipped cream, and more caramel!

back to top

Gluten Free Crusts are available by special order for most pies. Please order at least 48 hours in advance. There is a $2 per pie upcharge for the gluten free crust.

Cream Pies

All cream pie fillings are handmade in our kitchen from scratch - no boxed fillings or store-bought puddings here! Then, we top them with our secret recipe real whipped cream. NOT ALL PIES ARE AVAILABLE AT ALL TIMES; PLEASE CALL FOR AVAILABILITY.

Whole cream pies are available by special order with 48-hour advance notice required.

 

Banana Cream

Creamy, handmade vanilla pudding flavored with spiced rum, layered with sliced bananas in a golden, flaky crust and topped with homemade whipped cream whipped to perfection. Seasonal, 48-hour notice for special orders.

 

Butterscotch Cream PIe

Rich butterscotch cream deeply layered in our world famous flaky crust topped with our secret recipe homemade whipped cream. Whole pies by special order only, please order 48 hours in advance to assure that we have only the finest ingredients on hand. An old fashioned delight!

 

Chocolate Cream

Our homemade chocolate pudding is fudgy and dark with the slight flavor of spiced rum. It’s topped with homemade whipped cream  and cradled in our flaky crust.

 

Coconut Cream

Lightly-toasted coconut combined with coconut rum and vanilla in our handmade vanilla pudding in a flaky single crust and topped with homemade whipped cream and toasted coconut.

 

Custard

Old-fashioned pie at its best with a smooth, creamy pudding made with just the right blend of eggs, cream, sugar, and nutmeg. Simplicity packed with goodness and flavor! Seasonal, 48-hour notice for special orders.

Raisin Sour Cream

Raisins, cinnamon, nutmeg, rum, and sour cream added to our homemade pudding and placed in a golden flaky crust. Homemade whipped cream adds the finishing touch.

back to top

Gluten Free Crusts are available by special order for most pies. Please order at least 48 hours in advance. There is a $2 per pie upcharge for the gluten free crust.

Seasonal & Specialty Pies

Seasonal pies such as rhubarb and strawberry rhubarb are made when these fruits are at their best. We love to make traditional holiday pies, especially pumpkin so that the heavenly smell of baking pumpkin pies can fill the kitchen and the shop. Special orders are happily accepted for Seasonal & Specialty pies any time of year.

NOT ALL PIES ARE AVAILABLE AT ALL TIMES; PLEASE CALL FOR AVAILABILITY.

To ensure your favorite is available, it is recommended that you pre-order whole pies 48 hours in advance.

 

Cranberry Nut

Cranberries soaked in orange juice and then mixed with butter, eggs, sugar, walnuts, and white chocolate in a single crust for a tangy, sweet, melt-in-your-mouth pie. (Usually available November and December.)

 

Eggnog Custard

Celebrate the holidays with the festive flavors of eggnog and rum added to our creamy custard. (Usually available November and December.)

 

Key Lime

A traditional pie in a graham cracker crumb crust using fresh limes for a burst of lime flavor. (Usually available June through August.)

 

Peppermint Chocolate Silk

Our fudgy, dark chocolate silk pie combined with peppermint. The whipped cream topping is laced with shredded chocolate and peppermint. (Usually available November and December.)

 

Pumpkin

Grandma's recipe blends honey and whipping cream with pumpkin, cinnamon, nutmeg, allspice, cloves, and ginger. The sweet and spicy pumpkin taste lingers in your mouth and reminds one why pumpkin pie is a holiday favorite. (Usually available October through December.)

Pumpkin Cream Cheese

Our favorite pumpkin filling with a layer of cream cheese and covered with a streusel topping made with brown sugar, flour, butter, and pecans. (Usually available October through December.)

 

Pumpkin Pecan

Combines two of the holidays' most popular pies - pecan and pumpkin. A traditional pecan filling tops a layer of pumpkin and spices in our golden flaky crust. (Usually available October through December.)

 

Rhubarb or Strawberry Rhubarb

A springtime favorite of tangy rhubarb in a double crust pie. Strawberries provide an extra burst of sweetness in the Strawberry Rhubarb version. (Usually available May and June.)

 

Rhubarb Custard

A double crust pie filled with rhubarb, eggs, sugar, vanilla, and cream that is asweeter than a traditional rhubarb pie. (Usually available May and June.)

Canadian Maple

Creamy rich maple custard with a ring of maple-infused homemade whipped cream. (Usually available March through May.)

back to top

Gluten Free Crusts are available by special order for most pies. Please order at least 48 hours in advance. There is a $2 per pie upcharge for the gluten free crust.

6-Inch Pies & Pie Cookies

Select pies are available daily as a 6-inch pies. Pie Cookies flavors may vary by day and location,

Gluten free Pie Cookies available on weekends at both locations.

 

Blueberry

A traditional pie packed with the mouth-watering goodness of just blueberries in a flaky double crust.

 

BumbleBerry

A combination of strawberries, raspberries, blueberries,and blackberries with just the right combination of sweet/tart in a flaky double crust.

Blackberry Raspberry

A delicious combination of luscious berries. Sweet/tart enveloped in our famous double crust.

 

Cherry

The old-fashioned flavor of a traditional cherry pie made with tart cherries in a flaky double crust.

Pie Cookies

  • Blueberry

  • Raspberry

  • Nutella

Other flavors available by special order.

Gluten free pie cookies available by special order.

Gluten Free Crusts are available by special order for most pies. Please order at least 48 hours in advance. There is a $2 per pie upcharge for the gluten free crust.

back to top

Stockholm Pie and General Store
N2030 Spring Street, Stockholm, Wisconsin, 54769 P: 715.442.5505